Pin It

Claws Out: Nothing Hurts You Like Family 

Among the best films of 2005 was The Squid and the Whale, a dark drama that happens to be wickedly funny. If it leans a

click to enlarge Image
  • Image
Among the best films of 2005 was The Squid and the Whale, a dark drama that happens to be wickedly funny. If it leans a little heavily on Wes Anderson (Rushmore), it at least gives fans of Anderson a director to lionize in Noah Baumbach. Produced by Anderson, with whom Baumbach wrote The Life Aquatic, The Squid and the Whale is the story of Baumbach's parents' divorce, a bitter breakup told from the children's point of view. From the perspective of two awkward, bemused teenage boys, the arrogance and stubbornness of their parents - rival writers - feels unexpectedly light and whimsical. The script earned Baumbach an Oscar nomination and a number of passionate supporters. Now his follow-up, Margot at the Wedding, arrives with little fanfare but great expectations.

I suspect few people will see this film, and potentially a handful of people will enjoy it. I mention that because while I admire it very much, Margot at the Wedding is Squid without a safety net. There's no youthful, delicate point of view. Instead, the knives are bigger, the cuts are deeper and real blood (metaphorically speaking) is spilled. I'm still healing from my viewing of it. Yet, because it presents sibling rivalry so authoritatively, I hope to see it twice.

The story is deceptively simple. Margot (Nicole Kidman) arrives in Suffolk County, N.Y., with her son Claude (Zane Pais) for the wedding of her estranged sister Pauline (Jennifer Jason Leigh). Margot is without her husband, a condition that instantly makes her conspicuous; her son, who's teased for his girlish looks, is clingy to the degree that an intercession will be needed; and Pauline, gentle but brittle, wants to mend fences with Margot and get married, all at once. That will be difficult, given that the groom is Jack Black, who plays Malcolm, an ex-rocker, with all the restraint he can muster.

As for plot, that's about the sum of it. There are some feral neighbors, a dispute over a tree and an adulterous subplot with Margot and an old flame. But the scenario of Margot at the Wedding is subordinate to the way the film places its characters high on a wire and watches them teeter, flail and fight for survival. Margot isn't really about anything other than family, which in the end, of course, is everything. It's as literary as Alice McDermott's fine novel Child of My Heart, which happens to be set around the same people and places as Margot. Only Margot is darker.

Margot herself is insufferable, a term she likes to apply to others. She's the type of person who laments her sister's pregnancy because it means Pauline can't drink champagne with her. Despite her flaws, Margot briefly reconnects with Pauline - who frankly can't believe her sister came at all - until Margot reverts to leading Pauline through life, rather than simply supporting her. The film does a cunning job of setting up one sister as flighty and the other as responsible; before you know it, the fragile Pauline turns out to be strong, while the stable Margot turns out to be fragile. Margot at the Wedding is a hard road to travel. It can be cruel but it never ceases to be funny. The pace is breathless. There are no interstices: One meaningful scene follows the next without pause, leaving no room for music or those calm, reflective shots of nature so common in family dramas like The Ice Storm.

When Malcolm finds himself outside looking in, Black can't help making Margot at the Wedding a farce. There are a few rickety sequences in which Black's reactions upset the film. When the sisters (sans Black) end up in a motel room, the film slumps when it should be sliding to conclusion. I had the feeling of stepping off an escalator: My body wanted to know why it wasn't moving anymore. Then Margot and Pauline suddenly lurch forward in a way I couldn't completely accept. But the ride prior to this is so clearly mapped, I didn't let the detour get in the way.



Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

Latest in Film

  • Scare Your Pants Off

    The Source's picks for Halloween flicks, no matter what the crowd
    • Oct 26, 2016
  • Cruise Control

    "Jack Reacher" never grabs on
    • Oct 26, 2016
  • Little Boxes

    "The Accountant" makes up its own rules
    • Oct 19, 2016
  • More »

More by Jason Blair

  • The Great Escape: Quiet baseball drama is a champ

    It's actually a baseball movie...Sugar, the new film by the directors of Half Nelson, begins and ends with our hero atop a pitcher's mound. Tucked in between is a minor league season, one that elapses with all the boredom and fury you'd expect from a modern baseball drama. But baseball is a side attraction in Sugar, as mature and empathetic as any sports flick in recent memory. In the era of Eastbound and Down - HBO's terrific spoof of a clueless ex-pro baseballer - we can expect a glut of baseball satire, given what the game has done to itself. Meanwhile, Sugar has other scores to settle. It's about how easily undone are the dreams of being among the best at something, and how in order to be the best, it can be necessary to leave those we love behind. Sugar works as an immigrant saga, a coming-of-age story and a coming-down-to-earth cautionary tale. In short, Sugar is pure and honest, which is more than we can say for baseball itself.
    • Jun 3, 2009
  • The Late Ones: Two siblings care for the father who never did

    Nothing like a good ol' fashioned awkward moment...The Savages, the title of which refers to the characters' names as well as their predicament, is not, as luck would have it, another bleak film about people behaving badly. It can't avoid being a grim picture in places, what with its subject matter - the death of a parent by dementia - likely to provoke nearly universal feelings of dread. But writer/director Tamara Jenkins (Slums of Beverly Hills) presents The Savages as a tale of survival, one in which Wendy (Laura Linney) and her brother Jon (Philip Seymour Hoffman) reshuffle their lives when the father who abandoned them can no longer care for himself. It's a savage undertaking, to be sure, but Jenkins isn't interested in death as much as how death reorganizes the lives it doesn't take.
    • Jan 23, 2008
  • Charlie Wilson's War

    Pretty Woman II: Dirty DebutantesEarly in Charlie Wilson's War, a speaker intones that without Charlie Wilson, history "would be largely and sadly different." Whether history
    • Jan 9, 2008
  • More »

Readers also liked…

© 2016 LAY IT OUT INC | 704 NW GEORGIA, BEND, OREGON 97703  |   Privacy Policy

Website powered by Foundation