Pin It

Hot Air: Election dialogue only inflames us 

If history is any indicator, Oregon's latest tax measures have an uphill battle at the polls.

The point was underscored, perhaps a little unscientifically at a town hall-style debate in Bend earlier this week when Rep. Phil Barnhart, one of the Measures 66 and 67 chief proponents, took on one of the measures' biggest critics, Sen. Chris Telfer on her home turf. At times the meeting, which was taped for broadcast on Bend Broadband's Talk of the Town program, had the feel of an ambush.

I knew that things might be rough for Barnhart when someone started handing copies of the recent Oregonian editorial page under the mock headline "Obamagonian." From what I could gather the purveyor was distributing this as evidence that even the liberal media was opposed to the tax measures - apparently unaware that the Oregonian's famously conservative editorial page also twice endorsed George W. Bush. I bit my tongue. While show hosts Jamie Christman and Dave Jones did a nice job setting up the show, which will broadcast Monday Jan. 11 on COTV (Ch. 11), the rest of the evening or at least what I could bear followed in the same vein. A mix of small business owners and citizens angry at the size of government queuing up to give Barnhart a piece of their mind. Never mind that a majority of them will be barely impacted by the new taxes, if ratified by voters, as Barnhart pointed out to one business owner who refused to believe that her taxes would go up by just $150 per year.

Somehow, the entire first half of the program went off without a single comment in favor of the measures or a pointed question for Telfer who claims to be able to close a $755 million shortfall in the state's General Fund with an impractical mix of union contract renegotiations, raids on dedicated funds and a tapping of the state's fledgling rainy day reserve. Oh yeah, and cutting off funding for the Portland Art Museum. (total savings: $.33 million)

Barnhart, a Eugene-area democrat with a snow white beard and a scholarly demeanor, found a largely hostile audience in Telfer's hometown where tax opponents sometimes jeered the out-of-town's rep's attempts to explain the finer points of a tax proposal that he helped author. A cerebral politician who has a law degree from University of Oregon and is a board member of the Oregon Bach Festival, Barnhart represented a sharp stylistic contrast to Telfer's platitude pushing pit-bull. And it didn't play well for the local audience, many of whom, including a sizeable contingent from the city to the north, came spoiling for a fight.

Here's hoping that the rest of Oregon sees beyond the rhetoric.


Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

Latest in Commentary

  • Letter to the Bend-

    La Pine School Board
    • Mar 2, 2016
  • Bulletin Bankrupcy Chatter

    A week ago Tuesday the Bend Bulletin, one Central Oregon's largest employers and most venerable institutions, quietly joined the ranks of thousands of American homeowners and filed for bankruptcy. The newspaper as editor in chief John Costa explained in a rare front-page editorial was at an impasse with its chief creditor, none other than the beleaguered Bank of America. According to Costa and an accompanying front-page news story by staff reporter Sheila Miller, The Bulletin has seen its revenues drop by roughly 25 percent since the peak of the building boom circa 2006. The drop in revenue caused the paper miss several performance measures in its $18 million loan to B of A. The bank responded by raising the paper's interest rate to a penalty rate of 12 percent, nearly double the six percent originally agreed to. Costa and publisher Gordon Black shared that the paper had paid more than $2 million in penalties to B of A and had skipped several payments in an effort to get the loan re-adjusted, but to no avail.
    • Sep 1, 2011
  • The Phony Budget Crisis: The answer to America's fiscal woes is one we refuse to consider

    Everywhere you look, from the federal government to the states to your hometown, budget crises abound. Services are being slashed. Politicians and pundits from both parties tell us that the good times are over, that we've got to start living within our means. It's a lie Two case studies have made news lately: California, where new/old governor Jerry Brown is trying to close a $25 billion shortfall with a combination of draconian cuts in public services and a series of regressive tax increases, and Wisconsin, where right-winger Scott Walker says getting rid of unions would eliminate the state's $137 million deficit.
    • Mar 9, 2011
  • More »

More by Eric Flowers

Readers also liked…

© 2016 LAY IT OUT INC | 704 NW GEORGIA, BEND, OREGON 97703  |   Privacy Policy

Website powered by Foundation