Search
Username
Pin It
Favorite

Let's Call it a Draw 

In the fast and furious pond-or-river debate, some are calling for both

click to enlarge pond_rendering_copy.jpg

David Kinker

At last Wednesday's city council meeting, Mayor Jim Clinton held up a colorful painting of what could be. The rendering (pictured above) showed both a river and a pond—but no Newport Avenue dam, the 103-year-old, leaking structure that creates Mirror Pond.

Presented to murmuring approvals and head nods at the city council meeting, this new idea is the latest wrinkle in the ongoing debate.

And, what may seem at first blush, a silly can't-we-all-get-along hybrid (do we call it a rond, or a piver?), the river-and-pond idea is gaining popularity as a viable solution for the vexing problem that surrounds Mirror Pond, its dam and the silt-filled waters behind it. Ever since Wednesday's city council meeting, that consensus-finding concept artwork has gained significant traction on social media sites and among various local organizations and clubs. It has also captured the imagination of more than a few locals and elected officials.

"I think it's very, very attractive," said city councilor Victor Chudowsky of the river-and-pond painting. "Frankly, the more we look at the (Newport Avenue) dam, the more problematic it becomes," he added. Chudowsky also sits on the Mirror Pond Ad Hoc Work Group, a committee charged with providing direction to the city and the Bend Park & Recreation District.

Pacific Power owns the aging dam, but in late November, representatives from the utility company announced they were ready to divest their interests in the ailing structure. The announcement to ditch the dam wasn't a complete surprise; just a month earlier, a new breach was discovered in one of the dam's wooden bays—the third such breach in five years. Plus, the dam is hardly a revenue-generator, providing only enough power for a few hundred homes.

Meanwhile, city and park district representatives remain locked in tense negotiations with Pacific Power officials in hopes of finding an amendable way in which the utility company could unload the dam and still please the city and its citizens. But deciding the dam's ultimate fate, and that of Mirror Pond, still seems a long way off—especially when any solution, whether eliminating the dam or purchasing it outright, will likely cost millions.

As the debate rambles on, a few local groups, like the Bend Paddle Trail Alliance, an area recreation and conservation nonprofit, have decided to get off the sidelines and into the river-versus-pond game. Although BPTA has yet to take an official stance, it was BPTA members who put forward the suggested hybrid river-and-pond concept at Wednesday's city council meeting. They're pushing for what they call a win-win solution—one that unites rather than divides, and one that promises economic development and increased recreational opportunities.

"So far, everyone has been working against each other," said Jayson Bowerman, a BPTA board member and area kayaker. "It will take all of us working together to get this done."

The concept is simple: provide something for everyone, and in the most economical way possible.

The proposal is to do away with the failing Newport Avenue dam. By simply telling Pacific Power, "Thanks, but no thanks," the utility company would be responsible for decommissioning and removing the current dam as well as covering associated habitat restoration costs. In place of the Newport Avenue Dam, a new structure would be built upstream—possibly a bladder dam or weir, or perhaps something similar to the one planned for the Colorado Dam safe passage site even further upstream. Such a feature could, depending on the season, be manipulated to allow more or less river water to flow past it, all while allowing for fish passage. And the moving water would help flush silt downstream, Bowerman explained.

By creating this new structure, a version of Mirror Pond would remain, albeit one that doesn't stretch all the way to the Newport Avenue Bridge. And without the impediment of the Newport Avenue dam, all the segments of the Deschutes River Trail could finally be fully connected. The concept solution, it seems, would be a boon for fish and river habitat, nostalgic neighbors, environmentalists and river recreationalists.

Another clever aspect of the river-and-pond concept is that by running a small pipe from the pond to the current powerhouse, the city could create a micro-hydro option. Popular in Europe, the green energy solution would also serve as a work-around for the water rights issue associated with the Newport Avenue dam. As it stands today, the water right only allows water storage (the water that creates Mirror Pond) for power-generating purposes, though a park district attorney did suggest seeking a legislative exemption to the state rule.

"It's a totally legit concept and worth exploration," said Ryan Houston, executive director of the Upper Deschutes Watershed Council, of the river-and-pond concept. Houston has been involved with a number of dam removals and habitat restoration efforts. But, Houston said, the hybrid solution still presents a number of sticking points, such as possible silt accumulation.

"I think if Pacific Power is going to remove the dam, the absolute cheapest thing for the community is to let them do it," Houston added.

Pin It
Favorite

Speaking of...

Comments

Showing 1-1 of 1

Add a comment

 
Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-1 of 1

Add a comment

Join Our Newsletter

Latest in Local News

  • More Tax Breaks

    • May 23, 2018
    During a one-day special session, the Oregon Legislature passed a bill to add certain sole proprietorships to the list of businesses that can get more tax cuts. Was the effort worth it? More »
  • One Calamity Away

    • May 23, 2018
    The United Way of Deschutes County says nearly half of Central Oregon households can't afford basic necessities. Is the recession really over for working families?ALICE households in Central Oregon More »
  • A Quick Strip at Stars

    • May 23, 2018
    Stormy Daniels gave a decidedly brief performance in Bend last week; but one local reporter was there to catch the action Stormy's Sassy Six More »
  • More »

More by James Williams

Readers also liked…

  • Designing a Better Solution

    Designing a Better Solution

    Creators of The Housing Game offer a serious look at the hurdles to affordable housing
    • Oct 12, 2016
  • Eclipse Chasers

    Eclipse Chasers

    The Biggest Event of the Year: Why, Where and How to Watch the Great American Eclipse
    • Jan 4, 2017

© 2018 LAY IT OUT INC | 704 NW GEORGIA, BEND, OREGON 97703  |   Privacy Policy

Website powered by Foundation