It might be tough to believe, given the amount of ink that’s been spilled, but even before our latest story on local law enforcement, “Deputy ‘Dewey,’” we really wanted to stop writing about this topic for a while. The intrigues within the sheriff’s office and the various investigations into each of the candidates running for its highest office have been a fascinating study into the inner workings of the Deschutes County Sheriff’s Office. Among the important threads we uncovered through our reporting on the investigations into sheriff candidate James McLaughlin and sitting sheriff Ty Rupert, we discovered a pattern of the “blue” failing to cross that thin line and report on its own.
Last week’s story saw that thread continue — uncovering abuses of power and a laissez-faire attitude about reporting on those behind the thin blue line. “Deputy ‘Dewey’” outlined how a Deschutes County Sheriff’s deputy allegedly arrived at the sheriff’s gun range in a duty vehicle, smelling of alcohol to the point that police were called to investigate.
But when Oregon State Police officers arrived on scene to talk to the deputy in question, they failed to test the deputy’s blood alcohol, and closed their “investigation” within minutes, even though within DCSO, the deputy was placed on administrative leave that same day, and an independent investigator — the same one who looked into allegations against sheriff candidate McLaughlin — was hired to look into the matter.
It appears the sheriff’s office started out following protocol — except that, in violation of rules set out by Department of Public Safety Standards and Training, the office failed for months to fill out the form announcing the deputy’s leave of absence. [Clarification: While not discussing specific cases, Sheriff’s Office officials clarified that the type of leave an employee is on — administrative or protected, for example — may cause them to report that employee’s leave on a timeline that is not aligned with the initial investigation.]
Perhaps under average circumstances, where the public has a basic level of faith in its law enforcement offices, that last question around protocol [Editor’s note: this sentence has been changed from the original version to a “question of protocol” rather than a “failure to follow protocol,” per the clarification in the above paragraph] could have been seen as administrative error — but that’s not how things are here. The public wants to live in a world where they feel safe and comfortable in law enforcement— but that’s not how it is now. In this County, anonymous sources from outside and inside the department continually tip off reporters about internal misdeeds. Factions within DCSO are decidedly pro-incumbent sheriff or pro-challenger; each does what it can to discredit the other and in turn sow doubt for the public.
That’s why we wish we weren’t writing another editorial on the subject. How do we get to the place where this stuff is not happening — where anonymous moles don’t have anything to report to reporters, and where tribalist pockets don’t hold pitchforks, ready to spread more dirt? It’s great fun on social media, but it’s bad for a community who wants to have faith in its law enforcement officials. If the pandemic years brought out a latent mistrust in law enforcement and a desire to “defund the police,” the years in the wake of the Silver Rail tragedy are likely to bring out the opposite: A desire for a safe community where city police and the sheriff’s office are trusted partners.
During this year’s election season, many of the candidates for the Deschutes County Board of County Commissioners spoke of developing a County ombudsman’s office to oversee internal investigations, rather than continuing to shell out money to consultants only too happy to get paid to look into malfeasance at the sheriff’s office. The new commission should take this role seriously, and start that process, or begin a county charter process that codifies those positions within the County sphere. Also during the campaign, Sheriff Ty Rupert talked of forming a citizen’s review board — something he indicated he’d have in place “soon.”
Soon is now, and we’re still waiting.
This article appears in the Source November 19, 2026.






