Deschutes County Sheriff Lt. James McLaughlin filed a federal lawsuit against the County and his boss, Sheriff-elect Ty Rupert, on Oct. 21, alleging retaliation for exercising his First Amendment right to run against him.  

McLaughlin asserts that Rupert weaponized the sheriff’s public office after McLaughlin announced his running for sheriff in the November election. He seeks a jury trial to determine monetary damages, attorney’s fees and back pay.

The detective lieutenant also wants an acknowledgement from Rupert and the County of allegedly trampling his rights.

And he wants his job back.

DCSO Lt. James McLaughlin, left, has filed a federal lawsuit against his boss, Sheriff-elect Ty Rupert, and Deschutes County, several weeks after the two met with the Source editorial board at our office, Oct. 1. Credit: Peter Madsen

As of Nov. 13, Rupert has carried 68.50% of the unofficial votes in the election; McLaughlin received 30.03% of voters’ support. The Deschutes County Clerk’s Office will confirm final results by Nov. 30. 

McLaughlin is being represented by Randy Harvey, the same employment lawyer who represented then-Sheriff Kent van der Kamp during his arbitration with the state police certifying committee, which ultimately banned van der Kamp for life from working as a cop in Oregon. 

McLaughlin deferred all comments to Harvey, yet the attorney’s paralegal told the Source Harvey was not available for comment before press time. 

Jason Carr, the DCSO spokesperson, told the Source that neither he nor Rupert can comment on the pending lawsuit. Deschutes County Counsel David Doyle said the “defendants will vigorously defend against and contest the allegations and claims in the lawsuit filed by Mr. McLaughlin.” 

In the complaint, McLaughlin alleges he was punished by DCSO command staff for helping Deputy Michael Mangin with his arbitration against then-Sheriff Shane Nelson. McLaughlin also says he was retaliated against in early 2024 for supporting an effort among sergeants to join the Deschutes County Sheriff Employee’s Association, which was ultimately successful. 

McLaughlin says he made these efforts off the clock and, as such, it constituted First Amendment-protected speech. 

Several months later, Captain Paul Garrison served McLaughlin with an internal investigation, according to the complaint. When McLaughlin asked why, he alleges Garrison told him that everything would blow over after “silly season” — the then-current sheriff race between William Bailey and Kent van der Kamp. 

In early June 2024, McLaughlin served a written tort claim notice to Deschutes County Counsel, County leadership and DCSO asserting retaliation and infringement of his speech rights. 

That notice alleged that command authority against an employee’s protected political activity created a constitutional risk, according to the complaint. McLaughlin didn’t seek damages, instead using the tort to provide precedent and background of his infringed rights, according to the complaint. 

An alleged quid pro quo 

McLaughlin also alleges that Ty Rupert, a lieutenant at the time, sought his endorsement for interim sheriff, repeatedly urging him to not run against him. 

Over a dinner meeting at Rupert’s home with their wives present, McLaughlin says he told Rupert that he intended to run for sheriff and was considering seeking the interim appointment in the meantime.  

McLaughlin alleges that Rupert offered, as a reward for not running against him for the interim sheriff position, un-contested support for McLaughlin in the November sheriff election. 

Back at DCSO headquarters, McLaughlin alleges that Rupert called him into his office, told him that he knew what McLaughlin wanted and invited him to name the position or authority as enticement to not run against him. 

McLaughlin says he declined the offers, announcing his candidacy for sheriff on Jan. 26. 

Thereafter, McLaughlin says that DCSO “subsequently reduced his authority, access, and supervisory role; proposed a schedule change directed at time available for his off-duty campaign; excluded him from decisions within his own detective division; placed him on administrative leave; expanded an internal investigation; and publicly deployed disputed accusations bearing directly on honesty, integrity, and fitness to serve as sheriff.” 

On June 5, Rupert placed McLaughlin on administrative leave, stemming from misconduct allegations sustained by third-party investigator Jim Band, who recommended Rupert fire McLaughlin.  

McLaughlin also alleges in his lawsuit that the Deschutes County Sheriff’s Office weaponized the pre-election release of that recommendation to OPB and the Source before providing the report to him and his counsel. 

The administrative investigation into McLaughlin, Mangin and Sgt. David Turkington is still technically active, yet the investigation into McLaughlin has been paused, per policy, since McLaughlin assumed a three-month family medical leave which expires Nov. 19.

$
$
$

We're stronger together! Become a Source member and help us empower the community through impactful, local news. Your support makes a difference!

Creative Commons License

Republish our articles for free, online or in print, under a Creative Commons license.

Trending

Deputy ‘Dewey’Deputy ‘Dewey’November 11, 2026Peter Madsen
Sandwich Week: A RecapSandwich Week: A RecapNovember 10, 2026Nicole Vulcan
Mt. Bachelor Lift Mechanics Push to UnionizeMt. Bachelor Lift Mechanics Push to UnionizeNovember 13, 2026Clayton Franke

Peter is a feature & investigative reporter supported by the Lay It Out Foundation. His work regularly appears in the Source. Peter's writing has appeared in Vice, Thrasher and The New York Times....

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *